Contact Azane
Terms & Conditions
Star Refrigeration
  • Home
  • Products
  • Sectors
  • Case Studies
  • News
  • Why Low Charge Ammonia?
  • Videos
  • About Us
  • Careers

ASHRAE - How low can you go?

Published by ASHRAE | Written by Dr. Andy Pearson 

 

There has been a great deal of discussion in recent years of the merits of “low charge” systems. The incentives to follow this trend are diverse, ranging from the flammability of hydrocarbons or the toxicity of ammonia to the expected higher cost of the new fluids currently under development and not yet on the market. New technology has provided a further boost to the aspirations of system designers. Microchannel heat exchangers and innovative sensor technology enable plants to run on a fraction of the charge that was required back in the olden days when refrigerant was cheap and leaks didn’t seem to matter.

There are several apparently contradictory factors that emerge once you dive in to consider the implications of low charge design in more depth. It is misleading and potentially harmful to think that if low charge is good then lower charge must be better. If designing
for lower charge causes the system to be less reliable, then the operator (who has pies or milk or data to process) will not be impressed. Likewise, if low charge equals low efficiency, the business will suffer increased costs. Low charge is very much a case of “be careful what you wish for.”

It is also a mistake to equate lower charge with lower refrigerant loss. It is common to hear charge expressed as “pounds per ton” (or in metric, “kg/kW”). This is a useful measure for making a quick assessment of likely charge requirements but more than a moment’s thought can lead to some puzzling and perverse conclusions.

If a system with a charge of 1,000 pounds of refrigerant leaks at a rate of 10% per year, the owner has to buy 100 pounds of replacement each year. If this is replaced with a system that only has 100 pounds of charge but nothing is done to address the common causes of leakage then he still has to buy 100 pounds per year, but to keep the plant running reliably and efficiently he now has to buy in smaller quantities, more frequently and with more frequent service visits to match. There is no doubt that this low charge way of going about the business of cooling will be much more expensive in this case—and the operator will still not be impressed. Even worse, the common measure of system leakiness—the percent per year—will have been increased from 10% per year to 100% per year, which is horrific in anyone’s book. Now the operator is not only paying more to keep his plant running, he is also ashamed to show his figures in public because they are so bad. The converse also applies: the easiest way to improve the annual leak rate is to massively overcharge the system. This is good math but extremely bad practice.

The real benefit of designing a low charge system depends very much on the incentives mentioned at the top of the page. If refrigerant cost is the driver, for example the predicted cost of HFO blends when they reach the market, then eliminating leak sources is a greater imperative. Low charge design follows on the basis that once the regular trickles of refrigerant leakage have been eliminated then the occasional blow out—a total system loss—becomes the most significant danger. In this case low charge is beneficial
because there is less total to lose.

If management of flammability or toxicity is the issue, then the regular trickles are less of a concern and the imperative is to avoid sudden rapid loss that would lead to a hazardous situation developing. A low charge design is obviously beneficial. Once large loss has been designed out, the smaller leaks, which can be a timely warning of a growing problem, can be addressed on a regular maintenance basis. Different incentive; same end result.
To paraphrase Albert Einstein, “The charge should be as low as possible, but not lower.”

 

Andy Pearson, Ph.D., C.Eng., is Group Managing Director of the Star Refrigeration Group and President of group subsidiary Azane Inc, the leading US manufacturer of low charge ammonia chillers and freezers.  

This article was published in ASHRAE Journal, July 2016. Copyright 2016 ASHRAE. Reprinted here by permission from ASHRAE at www.azane-inc.com. This article may not be copied nor distributed in either paper or digital form by other parties without ASHRAE's permission. For more information about ASHRAE, visit www.ashrae.org.

Latest News
  • 20.11.2018
    Azane set new benchmark in low charge ammonia refrigeration technology at RETA National Conference 2018

    Leading US manufacturer of low charge ammonia refrigeration systems, Azane, have launched their new and imp...

  • 14.06.2018
    Azane Inc to promote widespread benefits of low charge ammonia at Gustav Lorentzen Conference on Natural Refrigerants

    Caleb Nelson, Vice- President of US low charge ammonia refrigeration manufacturer, Azane Inc, will present ...

  • 20.03.2018
    Azane Travels to IIAR 2018 Annual Natural Refrigeration Conference in Colorado

    Low charge ammonia chiller and freezer manufacturer, Azane Inc, is gearing up to exhibit at the IIAR 2018 N...

  • 26.09.2017
    Low charge ammonia manufacturer Azane to deliver technical ammonia paper at RETA National Conference 2017

    RETA’s conference  brings thousands of industry experts and manufacturers under one roof. Azane Inc will be...

  • 08.06.2017
    Azane Inc to showcase innovative low charge ammonia refrigeration systems at Global Cold Chain Expo in Chicago

    US low charge ammonia manufacturer, Azane Inc, will be sharing its innovations and years of experience in a...

  • 08.06.2017
    Azane-Inc to sponsor major industry event in California

    Azane Inc, a world-leading manufacturer of low charge ammonia refrigeration systems, is thrilled to announ...

Details

Azane-Inc
913 SW Higgins Ave
STE 105
Missoula MT. 59803

info@azane-inc.com
Tel: +1 888-882-9947

Products

Azanechiller 2.0
Azanefreezer

Sectors

Frozen Storage
Chilled Storage
Process Cooling
Leisure
HVAC Cooling

Star Refrigeration Group

Star Refrigeration
Star Technical Solutions
Starfrost
Star Learning Solutions
Star Renewable Energy
Star M & E Solutions
Azane

Follow @lowchargeNH3

©2007 - 2016 Star Refrigeration. All rights reserved.   Privacy Policy   Terms and Conditions